Honest Feedback to Improve Philanthropy

Welcome to Philamplify – where expert assessments and community feedback meet to maximize the impact of grantmaker giving. Together we’re creating a comprehensive picture of philanthropic practices that work and areas where we can all improve.

Honest Feedback to Improve Philanthropy

Welcome to Philamplify – where expert assessments and community feedback meet to maximize the impact of grantmaker giving. Together we’re creating a comprehensive picture of philanthropic practices that work and areas where we can all improve.

“I am eager to see grantmakers, nonprofits and members of our communities come together to provide critical feedback that will make philanthropic resources more effective at solving the world’s toughest problems. ”-- Ruth Messinger, President, American Jewish World ServiceShare Your Stories

Latest Foundation Assessments

Oregon Community Foundation

The Oregon Community Foundation engages a large network of volunteers and donors across the state to support local concerns. Can it also build a statewide legacy of equity and inclusion?

Read More and Decide

New York Community Trust

The New York Community Trust has a strong commitment to equity and meeting community needs. Can it build on its strengths to become a true public leader in New York City?

Read More and Decide

John S. and James L. Knight Foundation

The Knight Foundation has an admirable commitment to risk and innovation. Can the foundation look beyond #ShinyBrightObjects and do more to promote equity?

Read More and Decide

The Kresge Foundation

Although Kresge exceeds most of NCRP’s criteria for effective social justice philanthropy by working with low-income communities to address systemic urban issues, the foundation needs to explicitly integrate a racial equity lens throughout its work.

Read More and Decide

Hess Foundation

Hess Foundation grantees love that it provides unrestricted support with minimal reporting requirements. But the foundation’s lack of transparency and communication with grantees limits its impact on the communities it serves.

Read More and Decide

Walton Family Foundation

The Walton Family Foundation's market-oriented approach has led to some successes and some disappointing outcomes.

Read More and Decide

The California Endowment Assessment

The California Endowment is a national leader in bringing health equity to the Golden State. While the Endowment is already doing a lot of things right, it could have an even greater impact.

Read More and Decide

Daniels Fund Assessment

The Daniels Fund is one of Colorado's most important grantmakers. In examining the foundation, we ask: Is donor intent compatible with strategic, social justice philanthropy? The issues are complex but the answer is yes.

Read More and Decide

William Penn Foundation Assessment

While William Penn is highly lauded for its work on pre-K, the environment and the arts, it has encountered bumps in the road during changes in leadership and strategic direction.

Read More and Decide

Woodruff Foundation Assessment

The Woodruff Foundation is doing even more than it appears at first glance to help marginalized communities. But it could achieve even greater impact by convening nonprofits to tackle pressing issues and bringing more diverse voices into its decision-making process.

Read More and Decide

Lumina Foundation Assessment

Lumina has been successful in calling attention to the problem of low college attainment rates, especially for marginalized students. However, experts and community members share ideas on what Lumina can improve upon to achieve its ambitious goals.

Read More and Decide
View on Twitter

NCRP

7/25/16 at 1:58pm

Can @TheOregonCF Build a Statewide Legacy of #Equity & Inclusion? https://t.co/qd3PGJytZr #philanthropy #Philamplify https://t.co/qyMAH7307o

View on Twitter

AmeriCorps Alums SD

7/24/16 at 3:05pm

RT @NCRP: Should community #foundations connect donors to underserved communities? Vote in our latest #Philamplify poll! https://t.co/U7nvs…

View on Twitter

Christine Newman

7/22/16 at 1:19pm

RT @NCRP: Should community #foundations connect donors to underserved communities? Vote in our latest #Philamplify poll! https://t.co/U7nvs…

View on Twitter

Sharon59

7/22/16 at 12:58pm

RT @NCRP: Should community #foundations connect donors to underserved communities? Vote in our latest #Philamplify poll! https://t.co/U7nvs…

Learn More

Guest

7/7/16 at 8:46pm

Choice, competition and market driven evaluation is a good thing. The government monopoly in delivering most education is failing.

Learn More

Guest

6/27/16 at 6:22pm

We have known for quite some time that foundation giving intentional for marginalized populations remains low thanks to NCRP's reports. However, shouldn't we expect more from community foundations, hence the first word in their name? I have seen some require diversity hiring practices and initiatives of their grantees while they don't practice them themselves. Maybe they're preoccupied with donor advised funds and their time and attention is taken away from such matters. Hopefully this piece will not only raise awareness and generate discussion in Oregon but within the 'community' of community foundations.

Learn More

Guest

6/24/16 at 9:54pm

That Caitlin Duffy is amazing!

Learn More

Caitlin

6/23/16 at 1:50pm

Thank you for your comment, Hilary. When you describe “smaller, not particularly diverse communities,” do you mean majority white, rural communities? Rural communities are indeed underresourced by philanthropy. Our report affirms the great work OCF has done to ensure its grantmaking reaches geographically diverse, rural communities through its regional offices and extensive donor and volunteer networks.

As OCF’s assets and grantmaking continue to grow, and as it moves forward with its commitment to equity, diversity and inclusion, we recommend that OCF’s grantmaking better reflect the demographic diversity of the state. A commitment to equity includes support of all underserved communities, small and large alike, including rural and communities of color.

Communities of color make up 23 percent of Oregon’s population and have been historically marginalized and underfunded. In fact, as we write in the report, because of the changing demographics of the state “’rural’ cannot and should not be equated exclusively with white communities.” For example, “Latinos make up more than a quarter of the population in five more rural counties.” We discuss the history of Oregon's racial/ethnic demographics and disparities in the report's Background section from pgs 11-15.

View on Facebook

National Committee for Responsive Philanthropy (NCRP)

7/27/16 at 4:08pm

National Committee for Responsive Philanthropy (NCRP) shared Neighborhood Funders Group's photo.

View on Facebook

National Committee for Responsive Philanthropy (NCRP)

7/27/16 at 4:07pm

National Committee for Responsive Philanthropy (NCRP) shared Neighborhood Funders Group's photo.

View on Facebook

National Committee for Responsive Philanthropy (NCRP)

7/27/16 at 4:00pm

"It's not a good practice to have family members as paid staff," said Aaron Dorfman, executive director of the National Committee for Responsive Philanthropy, a foundation watchdog. "It's hard to hold family members accountable for good performance." http://trib.in/2ablJEk #philanthropy #DwyaneWade

View on Facebook

National Committee for Responsive Philanthropy (NCRP)

7/27/16 at 1:56pm

Awarding a three-year grant to a community group gives the company just one press opportunity to promote itself in the community, while annual grants give three. bit.ly/2abieOd

View on Google +

National Committee for Responsive Philanthropy

7/26/16 at 3:50pm

Overtime Rules Are Good for Nonprofits — and Good for America http://bit.ly/2aodK3t

View on Google +

National Committee for Responsive Philanthropy

7/22/16 at 10:04am

Four steps foundations should take to address racial equity http://bit.ly/29YW6qk

View on Google +

National Committee for Responsive Philanthropy

7/14/16 at 9:35am

NCRP: Coming soon to your favorite #podcast http://bit.ly/29FvRF2

View on Google +

National Committee for Responsive Philanthropy

7/12/16 at 12:06pm

With Millions at Stake, Some Foundations Slash Consulting Budgets http://bit.ly/29NZ9xV

How Philamplify Works

About Philamplify. Philamplify fosters an environment of transparency and honest feedback among foundations and nonprofits.

Learn More

The Latest News & Postings. Philamplify challenges philanthropic leaders to make unvarnished feedback an integral part of our culture, and sparks dialogue on how we can improve.

Learn More

Join the conversation. Philamplify provides everyone touched by philanthropy with an opportunity to share experiences and discuss what is needed from foundations to make real and lasting social change in our communities.

Learn More